Need help with color for bridesmaid shoes?

With your dresses being short either color will work, but I agree with what was written previously about the champagne shoes being an option because they can be used again. If you are wrapping the bouquet stems in a ribbon use the champagne color so it will tie in the two colors and if you can find the color you want in ribbon give a piece to your bridesmaids so that they can find their own shoes in that color. Being able to pick your own shoes helps the bridesmaids to save money and find a shoe that they will be comfortable in for the duration of your wedding day.